Heejun Han was all set up to be a William Hung but ended up being a Korean Michael Bolton.
Reed Grimm must be related to Casey Abrams. I don't know if that's good or bad.
Samantha Novacek and Patricia should be made to walk the plank with their lame planking act. It doesn't matter that Samantha can sing some.
Creighton Fraker is a faker. Sure he has skills, but he and his voice are thinner than a wafer.
Eben Franckewitz looks and sounds too young. Travis Orlando should just give it up. Idol is not the answer.
Erika Van Pelt can drive to Hollywood and do some gigs if she gets cut.
It would be nice to get Shane Bruce out of the coal mine, but his voice was not good enough to pull him out.
Hallie Day is perfect for Idol. A girl who ran away with a girl group as a teen, then came home and attempted suicide. Perfect. But she does show the experience of having been in a singing group with her vocal control.